| Adam Cannon (Columbia) | |
242 | 41 % |
| Robin Kelley (DISQUALIFIED) | |
53 | 9 % |
| Harvey Mansfield (Harvard) | |
42 | 7 % |
| Kevin McLaughlin (Brown) | |
85 | 14 % |
| Jean Jacques Poucel (Yale) | |
97 | 16 % |
| Jonathan Spence (Yale) | |
71 | 12 % |
Total votes: 590