- IvyGate - http://www.ivygateblog.com -
Brown Student Radio Gets Lawyered Off the Airwaves By Private School
Posted By Samier Saeed On September 6, 2011 @ 3:00 pm In Uncategorized | 6 Comments
Point: Brown is a thriving hippie commune, where cool is uncool (and vice versa) and alty-proggy musical mish-mosh takes the day.
Counterpoint: Absolutely not! Who peddles these stereotypes? (Certainly not us here at IvyGate.) The student body can be astonishingly, even disappointingly normal. Just look at all those Brown students diligently studying economics with the intention of going into banking or consulting (albeit with some shame).
As it turns out, both sides seem kind of hopeless, as evinced by a recent debacle in which Brunonians were outmaneuvered by the managers of a day school — thus damaging the stature of an independent, student-run radio station (a hipster’s platonic ideal) and making Brown kids look like bungling negotiators in the process.
Here’s the story: Brown Student Radio was leasing its radio signal from The Wheeler School, a private academy (N-12) that practically sits on Brown’s campus. A menagerie of modern glass and steelwork attached to old fashioned red-brick buildings, the school would blend perfectly into Brown’s campus if it weren’t so well maintained.
As if it wasn’t embarrassing enough that Brown students had to rent their signal from a secondary school, consider the fact that the administrators from said institution effectively lawyered the hell out of BSR just the other week. Wheeler administrators apparently “‘slipped in a clause’ that allowed them to terminate [the] lease only 15 days in advance” according to the Brown Daily Herald. They slipped it in, and then they used it. BSR concluded 14 years of analog broadcasting on August 1st, when Wheeler abruptly terminated the lease.
“Slipped in”, you say? As in to imply this happened without BSR’s noticing? And they only learned about it when they were shown the door? If that’s true, then it’s pretty embarrassing. But it’s not exactly the case.
Station Manager Erik-Dardan Ymeraga told IvyGate recently that “[the school has] generally been able to dictate terms, leaving us without much room to negotiate.” He adds that “past leadership would have read over the contract, as would have the relevant University offices, so yes [BSR was aware of the clause].” The organization attempted to win back the contract, applying against other candidates for the signal it was already renting. However, it ultimately lost to Rhode Island Public Radio, a company “with more political clout,” according to the Herald.
So maybe they aren’t the comically naive Brown students they originally seemed, but they definitely got screwed. Fifteen days is like a blink of an eye, and it’s hard not to reach the conclusion the folks at Wheeler behaved a bit like pricks. In speaking with the Herald, BSR Station Manager Ryan Lester characterized Wheeler’s move as a “free market decision.” But it also seems to be more than just cutthroat business maneuvering.
Ymeraga told us that “the way it was handled just seemed … off somehow after such a longstanding partnership.” And as he points out, there wasn’t even another lover, so to speak, when the contract got cancelled. Though Rhode Island Public Radio is finalizing negotiations to take over the signal, nobody has been broadcasting on it for the past month. So, Wheeler dumped BSR with little warning, and then — as if to rub it in — let the signal sit idle. That isn’t just getting jilted. It’s a vindictive break-up over Facebook chat.
(BSR shouldn’t feel too bad, though: The Wheeler School is expert at fleecing people. There are about 1554 parents happily getting screwed by them annually.)
The radio station is currently broadcasting online. And, on the plus side, they are no longer subject to Wheeler’s stringent restrictions on their content. They’ll funnel the money they would have used to pay their lease to improve their internet infrastructure. They look forward to “positive and progressive changes here.”
Article printed from IvyGate: http://www.ivygateblog.com
URL to article: http://www.ivygateblog.com/2011/09/brown-student-radio-gets-lawyered-off-the-airwaves-by-private-school/
Click here to print.
Copyright © IvyGate Media. All rights reserved.
6 Comments To "Brown Student Radio Gets Lawyered Off the Airwaves By Private School"
#1 Comment By Brown13 On September 6, 2011 @ 10:39 pm
Just want to point out that this isn’t Brown’s only radio station. They also run WBRU which is a completely student run commercial radio station that broadcasts all over southern new england and competes with the big corporation channels.
#2 Comment By John McGarry On September 7, 2011 @ 12:40 am
Acknowledging that this “news” blog basically exists for the lolz of smug undergrads, I feel compelled to correct some misreported and misleading statements and to offer a more balanced, if also biased, account of this deal:
— Perhaps it was slightly disappointing and disheartening that BSR has been a tenant to a day school’s signal, but if you know about the history of the station and of radio at the school, it’s not quite embarrassing. As noted in the first comment, BSR is the second, younger station at Brown. WBRU is now a commercial behemoth spreading alt-rock over one of New England’s strongest signals. Admirable to some, but not exactly college or community radio. Which is where BSR stepped in in ’97, as an offshoot of radio nerds who kickstarted a new student group and finagled a lease with Wheeler, no small feat. If you have any interest in finding out the rest of the story of radio at Brown, this audio documentary (bit.ly/BSRDoc), produced by BSR and BRU alums, is a good place to start.
— Characterizing the termination of the WELH lease as something “only learned about it when they were shown the door” and as something to “win back” is at best a misguided interpretation of the facts and at worst misleading and blatantly false. The facts of the lease were that BSR was one of a handful of part-time tenants on the WELH signal. We signed contracts to lease broadcast time from the owner, the Wheeler Schoool, as did other broadcasting groups. The exact terms of the contracts, such as broadcast hours and length of contract, have fluctuated over the years. BSR has always lived under the very real possibility of losing its terrestrial signal. Threats to our continued tenancy had come up before and, as an organization, we had spent many hours over the years preparing for such a possibility. We just, until last year, would have been given a few more weeks’ notice prior to losing it.
— Furthermore, the termination was nowhere near as abrupt nor as unexpected to BSR management as this article makes it out to be. The station was not idly cruising along debating which Pavement album is the best, as much as this article suggests otherwise; rather, we made the only prudent and proper business decision and kept such a large and confidential process behind closed doors. The situation was not ‘Wheeler kicks us off without notice then we try to win them back’. The owner approached multiple potential operators, solicited proposals, and choose the one which they determined to be the most advantageous for their organization, as is their legal right. This process took months from start to finish, and the station was busy planning for the consequences of both successful and unsuccessful bids for that entire duration (or even longer). Obviously, we would have rather them chosen ourselves, and perhaps would have benefited from a little more notice or forthcomingness, but such is the world of business.
— A fact not mentioned in this article nor the linked Daily Herald article is that within the past few years, Wheeler was granted a massive power upgrade on the signal, which no doubt increased its market value. This fact is more than likely the primary mover behind the Wheeler School’s motions to consolidate to a single operator, rather than a mixture of part-time tenants.
— Finally, the second half of this statement is outright untrue: “Though Rhode Island Public Radio is finalizing negotiations to take over
the signal, nobody has been broadcasting on it for the past month.” The smallest amount of legwork, entailing tuning into WELH via their website or a radio (should you live in the area/remember what they are), would have shown the station to still have content— the Wheeler School did produce content even when leasing parts of the signal, and presumably is continuing to do so while the deal is inked. This is actually the norm for signal cases like these— it’s in the interest of the owner of the signal to keep the area clean for the new operator and to avoid complication with overlapping leases/contracts. E.g. the loss of one of the best freeform stations in the country, KUSF (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KUSF / http://savekusf.org/), to a classical station who already broadcasts on the signal though the deal is not officially finalized.
Written by a former BSR manager, as well as a whole lot of other things around the station, current programmer/station member, former Brown student and Providence resident.
P.S.— For more information, you can visit bsrlive.com or read an article, which includes an interview with one of our publicity directors, from the beginning of last month when this all happened here: http://www.radiosurvivor.com/2011/07/25/brown-student-radio-station-bsr-to-go-online-only-august-1/
#3 Comment By Jon Mack On September 7, 2011 @ 1:26 am
Help! Long comment. This the internet, short attention span zone.
#4 Comment By Eww On September 7, 2011 @ 1:55 am
what a poorly written article.
#5 Comment By John On September 7, 2011 @ 3:42 am
Jon Mack, as an ‘aspiring novelist’, I am rather surprised and saddened that you did not take the few minutes to read Mr. McGarry’s reply. It’s not fiction, but worth reading nonetheless.
The fact that this article is grossly misleading is heavily muted by the embarrassing attempt at humor and overall tactless writing. From what I can tell, that’s what the Ivy Gate Blog does really well.
#6 Comment By BSR 13 On September 7, 2011 @ 6:48 pm
Wrong, BSR is the only station Brown funds; BRU is a commercial enterprise with no ties to the school save for the students running it.