Yale Movement for Beauty and Justice Founder: French Vacations, Dead Bunnies… Political Campaigns?

It feels like just yesterday that IvyGate introduced you to the willowy, manic, bunny-loving Justine Kolata, ’12: founder of Yale’s most vapid and unintentionally offensive extracurricular, “The Movement for Beauty and Justice.” In our cattier days, we were fairly harsh on the confused freshmodel, as she pranced around faux-philosophizing. The idea that a fetishization of aesthetic “beauty” — which, as any History major can tell you, has contributed to genocide, war, eating-disorder epidemics, etc. — could cure all of the world’s ills… well, it struck us as a little irresponsible. There’s a reason we don’t call “Art Museums,” “Beauty Museums.” A reason why Beauty (tea-cups, stargazing, and floral arrangements) rarely = Justice. And a reason why power-brokers — Ivy and non-Ivy grads alike — have done pretty despicable things in the pursuit of glittering “pretty” things (gold, land, blonde-hair-and-blue-eyes etc.)

We’d like to think we live in less scathing days, so for now, we’ll go easy. Surely things couldn’t get any worse than that misguided freshman year mistake? Unintentional ideological commonalities with Mein Kampf aside, Justine seems very nice…

After all, she recently invited ALL OF YALE to spend the summer at her family’s Villa house in the South of France (pictured left). Yeah, really. Justine spammed all of her Facebook friends with promises of “medieval villages, horses, french markets, cheese, wine, hiking, paleolithic caves, wonderful art, jazz and opera concerts etc.,” open to anyone who is “nice.”

Perhaps this is Justine’s way of publically mourning the death of Beauty and Justice. No, not the ineffable metaphysical concepts she fails to grasp, silly! Her two pet rabbits, named Beauty and Justice–the Movement’s adorable mascots–passed away two weeks ago; according to the YDN, “the first died of natural causes and the second of loneliness.”

Or perhaps the faux-Euromantic villa excursion has a more cynical goal in mind: buttressing Justine’s nascent political career! Yes, Ms. Kolata–after her extensive experience with tea-preparation, pastry-baking, and mass contempt–is running for Yale College Council Vice President… but actually Junior Class Council President. What the hell? All that we know is this campaign video–featuring a man with a whip, Justine reading from a script hidden in a Law School book she claims is “Shakespeare,” awkward grinding attempts, self-caricaturing, and the lyrics “don’t trust a ho, never trust a ho”–is nothing short of sublime:

It’s so nice to see that our old friends are keeping busy.

  • Y10

    STOP WRITING ABOUT THE YCC
    NO ONE CARES
    (AT YALE OR ANYWHERE ELSE)

  • Y10

    STOP WRITING ABOUT THE YCC
    NO ONE CARES
    (AT YALE OR ANYWHERE ELSE)

  • dartmouth

    “The idea that a fetishization of aesthetic “beauty”–which, as any History major can tell you, has been responsible for genocide, war, eating-disorder epidemics, etc.–could cure all of the world’s ills… well, it struck us as a little irresponsible.” Speaking of faux-philosophizing, I would be really interested to learn where you’ve been reading about this vast domain of aesthetics that isn’t related to “beauty.” You seem to be getting your information from Yale’s most famous [h]istory major, G***** W. B***; despite the number of Benjamin essays you’ve skimmed in the process of your liberal arts education, I don’t think that a direct line can be drawn from fascist aesthetics to death camps. A number of notable non-fascists held beauty to be the highest order of truth, such as Plato, nearly every Renaissance poet, Baudelaire (l’art pour l’art — clearly a crypto-Nazi/Soviet slogan), &c. I give this a 9/10 on the David Brooks scale of historical inaccuracies and lazy sophistry.

  • dartmouth

    “The idea that a fetishization of aesthetic “beauty”–which, as any History major can tell you, has been responsible for genocide, war, eating-disorder epidemics, etc.–could cure all of the world’s ills… well, it struck us as a little irresponsible.” Speaking of faux-philosophizing, I would be really interested to learn where you’ve been reading about this vast domain of aesthetics that isn’t related to “beauty.” You seem to be getting your information from Yale’s most famous [h]istory major, G***** W. B***; despite the number of Benjamin essays you’ve skimmed in the process of your liberal arts education, I don’t think that a direct line can be drawn from fascist aesthetics to death camps. A number of notable non-fascists held beauty to be the highest order of truth, such as Plato, nearly every Renaissance poet, Baudelaire (l’art pour l’art — clearly a crypto-Nazi/Soviet slogan), &c. I give this a 9/10 on the David Brooks scale of historical inaccuracies and lazy sophistry.

  • y11

    I think Kolata may be the only person at Yale more afraid of being unliked than you, Alex. You two should get together.

  • y11

    I think Kolata may be the only person at Yale more afraid of being unliked than you, Alex. You two should get together.

  • H 10

    Yeah WTF Ivygate. It sounds like the author of this article only has a second-hand understanding of aesthetics. Have you read Schiller? In his belief, the attainments of aesthetics is the only way to provide a workable social order. Have you read Kant’s Critique of Judgment? Even though I generally despise her, have you read Scarry’s On Beauty and Being Just? Addison? No? Didn’t think so. To say the attainment of beauty is the motivation for so many wrongs is one of the more idiotically myopic claims you can make, and the fact you write with regurgitated over-simplifications only makes you look like an idiot.

  • H 10

    Yeah WTF Ivygate. It sounds like the author of this article only has a second-hand understanding of aesthetics. Have you read Schiller? In his belief, the attainments of aesthetics is the only way to provide a workable social order. Have you read Kant’s Critique of Judgment? Even though I generally despise her, have you read Scarry’s On Beauty and Being Just? Addison? No? Didn’t think so. To say the attainment of beauty is the motivation for so many wrongs is one of the more idiotically myopic claims you can make, and the fact you write with regurgitated over-simplifications only makes you look like an idiot.

  • H 10

    Sorry ‘Justine,’ but you’re not really helping your case here. You say “the beauty I am talking about is beauty in nature, and art, and culture, and positive social interactions,” which means, well, that you need to figure out what you mean when you say beauty before you call others’ interpretations ‘superficial.’ I’ve yet to read any theory of aesthetic beauty that doesn’t claim as its apotheosis nature–seriously, nature is beauty and art is our attempt to recreate it through our human means. Don’t discredit ‘aesthetic beauty,’ discredit this article’s author’s menial understanding of it. Your philosophy fails because you’re strangely inconsistent with it; though it seems noble, you need to actually sit down and think about it before you try to defend it again, especially to ivy league kids.

    Also ‘I couldn’t have been a complete idiot to get into Yale.’ Ever heard of a specious argument?

  • H 10

    Sorry ‘Justine,’ but you’re not really helping your case here. You say “the beauty I am talking about is beauty in nature, and art, and culture, and positive social interactions,” which means, well, that you need to figure out what you mean when you say beauty before you call others’ interpretations ‘superficial.’ I’ve yet to read any theory of aesthetic beauty that doesn’t claim as its apotheosis nature–seriously, nature is beauty and art is our attempt to recreate it through our human means. Don’t discredit ‘aesthetic beauty,’ discredit this article’s author’s menial understanding of it. Your philosophy fails because you’re strangely inconsistent with it; though it seems noble, you need to actually sit down and think about it before you try to defend it again, especially to ivy league kids.

    Also ‘I couldn’t have been a complete idiot to get into Yale.’ Ever heard of a specious argument?

  • @ H10

    Ur a dick. SHuddddup

  • @ H10

    Ur a dick. SHuddddup

  • y11

    Why was Justine’s comment deleted?? It was hilarious!

  • y11

    Why was Justine’s comment deleted?? It was hilarious!

  • Xander

    At the core of Justine’s philosophy is the understanding that beauty is relational. This is a truth that is lost on the post-modernists. In any case, Justine is just a sweet girl who, in committing to her ideas, draws more criticism from the mob than she deserves. Keep up the jeering, and I might just have to become an out-and-out fan.

  • Xander

    At the core of Justine’s philosophy is the understanding that beauty is relational. This is a truth that is lost on the post-modernists. In any case, Justine is just a sweet girl who, in committing to her ideas, draws more criticism from the mob than she deserves. Keep up the jeering, and I might just have to become an out-and-out fan.

  • ’11

    Why would you censor my comment saying that Justine is a delightful person? Maybe because it doesn’t fit into your ‘look at her she’s so crazy!’ narrative. Justine is eminently kind and wants this position so that she can do good things for yalies. Mocking her isn’t funny anymore… she mocks herself better than you do.

  • ’11

    Why would you censor my comment saying that Justine is a delightful person? Maybe because it doesn’t fit into your ‘look at her she’s so crazy!’ narrative. Justine is eminently kind and wants this position so that she can do good things for yalies. Mocking her isn’t funny anymore… she mocks herself better than you do.

  • dartmouth

    I’m a little offended that my acerbic and spiteful comments have yet to be deleted. I want to feel injustice! But, yeah, IvyGate has gone down the shitter.

  • dartmouth

    I’m a little offended that my acerbic and spiteful comments have yet to be deleted. I want to feel injustice! But, yeah, IvyGate has gone down the shitter.

  • H 10

    Dartmouth,

    That’s not necessarily true. If you recall, I had a comment that listed maybe 5 aesthetic theorists that completely discredit Klein’s bullshit claims, and you responded in reminder of his idiotic and mis-contextualized Kant quote from the Cornell fence fiasco. Ivygate has deleted both of our comments, even though they do little more than expose him as either a stupid or lazy scholar. Whatever integrity Ivygate once had was lost when they started deleting any comments that put their writers in a negative light.

  • H 10

    Dartmouth,

    That’s not necessarily true. If you recall, I had a comment that listed maybe 5 aesthetic theorists that completely discredit Klein’s bullshit claims, and you responded in reminder of his idiotic and mis-contextualized Kant quote from the Cornell fence fiasco. Ivygate has deleted both of our comments, even though they do little more than expose him as either a stupid or lazy scholar. Whatever integrity Ivygate once had was lost when they started deleting any comments that put their writers in a negative light.

  • Matt

    I did laugh when Justine was spotted in the Master’s office on the day her bunnies died. She was crying a river and demanding a Morse-sponsored funeral for them.

    That being said, she deserves major credit for being able to make fun of herself the way she did in that video. How many of us would be willing to do that? Not just make fun of the stereotypes that are held against us, but make fun of the flaws that we know to be at least partially true.

  • Matt

    I did laugh when Justine was spotted in the Master’s office on the day her bunnies died. She was crying a river and demanding a Morse-sponsored funeral for them.

    That being said, she deserves major credit for being able to make fun of herself the way she did in that video. How many of us would be willing to do that? Not just make fun of the stereotypes that are held against us, but make fun of the flaws that we know to be at least partially true.

  • YES

    This video is amazing!! Justine is a great person who has one of the best traits anyone can have: the ability to laugh at yourself. I hope she wins, as I’ve seen how hard she works on her projects. GO JUSTINE!!

  • YES

    This video is amazing!! Justine is a great person who has one of the best traits anyone can have: the ability to laugh at yourself. I hope she wins, as I’ve seen how hard she works on her projects. GO JUSTINE!!

  • alcibiades

    Moreover, Mr. Klein basically plagiarized the Kant reference in his article regarding the Cornell suicides from the article which he linked to in his post.

  • alcibiades

    Moreover, Mr. Klein basically plagiarized the Kant reference in his article regarding the Cornell suicides from the article which he linked to in his post.

  • http://www.prada-outlet-store.com prada

    Here elaborates the matter not only extensively but also detailly .I support the
    write’s unique point.It is useful and benefit to your daily life.You can go those
    sits to know more relate things.They are strongly recommended by friends.Personally
    I feel quite well.. http://www.prada-outlet-store.com

  • breitling replica watches
  • Real Madrid merchandise

    Excellent reproduction Arsenalmerchandise sells at resonable price.The Real Madrid merchandise with high quality and exclusive design.Choose one amazing of
    England Premiere League merchandise to highlight your life style.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_TK2O6O3T7USB47OOIR76L5RXYU Prateek Panchal

    In praise for justine…..we want his comment back :D
    Norwegian cruise lines